Skip to main content

Table 4 Rate of concordance of recommendations according to different sections in the primary analysis and sensitivity analysis

From: Concordance of recommendations across clinical practice guidelines for the management of hypertension in Southeast Asia with internationally reputable sources

 

2017 ACC/AHA guideline

2018 ESC/ESH guideline

Reference recommendations, No

Concordance, No. (%)

Reference recommendations, No

Concordance, No. (%)

Primary analysis

 Blood pressure measurementa

1

1 (100)

1

1 (100)

 Diagnosis of hypertensionb

5

1 (20.0)

4

3 (75.0)

 Investigations of patients with hypertensionc

11

4 (36.3)

10

4 (40.0)

 Lifestyle modificationsd

6

6 (100)

6

6 (100)

 Goal blood pressuree

8

0 (0)

7

0 (0)

 Pharmacotherapy for patients with hypertension and no comorbidityf

10

6 (60.0)

10

6 (60.0)

 Pharmacotherapy for patients with hypertension and comorbidityg

18

12 (66.7)

13

11 (84.6)

Sensitivity analysis excluding insufficient ratings

 Blood pressure measurementa

1

1 (100)

1

1 (100)

 Diagnosis of hypertensionb

5

2 (40.0)

4

4 (100)

 Investigations of patients with hypertensionc

11

5 (45.4)

10

4 (40.0)

 Lifestyle modificationsd

6

6 (100)

6

6 (100)

 Goal blood pressuree

8

0 (0)

7

0 (0)

 Pharmacotherapy for patients with hypertension and no comorbidityf

10

6 (60.0)

10

6 (60.0)

 Pharmacotherapy for patients with hypertension and comorbidityg

14

13 (92.9)

11

11 (100)

  1. ACC: American College of Cardiology; AHA: American Heart Association; ESC: European Society of Cardiology; ESH: European Society of Hypertension
  2. aACC-1; ESC-1
  3. bACC-2 to ACC-6; ESC-2 to ESC-5
  4. cACC-7 to ACC-17; ESC-6 to ESC-15
  5. dACC-18 to ACC-23; ESC-16 to ESC-21
  6. eACC-24 to ACC-31; ESC-22 to ESC-28
  7. fACC-32 to ACC-41; ESC-29 to ESC-38
  8. gACC-42 to ACC-59; ESC-38 to ESC-51