Skip to main content

Table 1 Baseline characteristics of included studies

From: Effects of intravenous hydration on risk of contrast induced nephropathy and in-hospital mortality in STEMI patients undergoing primary percutaneous coronary intervention: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

Study

Country, recruitment period

No. of patients randomized

Age ±SD/ (range)

Killip class > 1

eGFR

Intervention Arm

Delivered hydration in intervention groupa

CIN (%)

RRT(%)

In-hospital mortality (%)

HF /APE

Mean LOS (intervention; control) (days)

Maioli et.al.(2011)

Italy, July 2004–December 2008

461

65.0 ± 12.34

20.6% (93/450)

75.67 ± 21.71

Biocarbonate Solution:

3 mL/kg in 1 h, starting in the DR, 1 mL/kg per hour for 12 h after PCI, but reduced to 0.5 mL/kg in patients with LVEF≤40% or NYHA class III-IV

Normal Saline:

1 mL/kg per hour for 12 h immediately after PCI, but reduced to 0.5 mL/kg in patients with LVEF≤40% or NYHA class III-IV

Mean volume: 1021 ± 196 ml

20.6%(93/450)

0.9% (4/450)

3.5% (16/450)

Unknown

Unknown

Luo et.al.(2014)

China, August 2009–October 2012

216

67.0 (57–75)

35.6% (77/216)

70.55 ± 22.90

Normal Saline:

1 mL/kg per hour for 12 h after primary PCI, but reduced to 0.5 mL/kg.hr. in patients with LVEF≤30% or Killip class II-III

Mean rate: 0.75 ml/kg/hour

27.8% (60/216)

3.7% (8/216)

6% (13/216)

6% (13/216)

6.8 ± 25.7; 14.4 ± 30.5

Jurado-Román et.al.(2015)

Spain, July 2012–November 2013

408

62.8 ± 13.04

14.7% (60/408)

89 ± 40.97

Normal Saline:

1 mL/kg/h since the beginning of procedure and during the following 24 h, but reduced to 0.5 mL/kg in patients with LVEF< 40% or Killip class III-IV

Mean volume: 1720 ± 234 ml

14%(57/408)

1%

(3/303)

4.81%(15/312)

Unknown

6; 8.2

  1. ER emergency room, RRT Requirement for dialysis, HF heart failure, APE Acute pulmonary edema, LOS Length of stay. Other abbreviations as in study design
  2. aNo paper reported hydration volume or rate in the control group