Table 1 Study design and baseline characteristics
Study | Year | Design | Sample size | F/U Months | Age years | Male | DM | Hyperlipidemia | LVEF, % | Renal insufficiency | Smoker | Study quality (Max = 9) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
P Agostoni [13] | 2005 | Observational | 24/34 | 14 | 62/64 | 15/25 | 9/10 | 15/23 | 52/44 | NA/NA | 4/7 | 7 |
P Roy [14] | 2008 | Observational | 884/884 | 12 | 66/66 | 613/619 | 317/304 | 762/770 | 47/48 | 110/112 | 186/181 | 9 |
SJ Park [15] | 2009 | Observational | 145/145 | 36 | 64/65 | 102/102 | 49/49 | 42/44 | 60/61 | 7/6 | 28/30 | 9 |
SH Kim [16] | 2010 | Observational | 308/112 | 48 | 59/60 | 221/80 | 61/24 | 134/99 | 60/59 | 3/1 | 109/40 | 8 |
J Jakabcin [10] | 2010 | RCT | 105/105 | 18 | 59/60 | 77/75 | 44/47 | 66/69 | NA/NA | NA/NA | 42/37 | 4a |
JS Kim [17] | 2011 | Observational | 487/487 | 36 | 62/62 | 324/326 | 155/162 | 168/170 | 60/59 | 15/15 | 106/111 | 9 |
BE Claessen [18] | 2011 | Observational | 631/873 | 24 | 64/65 | 469/652 | 190/316 | 533/740 | NA/NA | 54/97 | 70/94 | 9 |
SH Hur [19] | 2011 | Observational | 2765/1816 | 36 | 59/62 | 1982/1240 | 622/463 | 1305/1108 | 59/57 | 83/105 | 979/636 | 7 |
KW Park [20] | 2012 | Observational | 619/802 | 12 | 62/63 | 393/524 | 233/309 | 468/610 | NA/NA | NA/NA | 147/233 | 8 |
SL Chen [21] | 2012 | Observational | 324/304 | 12 | 63/65 | 261/227 | 60/54 | 108/304 | 61/60 | NA/NA | 147/154 | 8 |
ADAPT-DES [4] | 2013 | Observational | 3349/5234 | 12 | 63/64 | 2457/3901 | 1048/1735 | 2287/4093 | NA/NA | 536/894 | 851/1088 | 9 |
Chieffo A [11] | 2013 | RCT | 142/142 | 24 | 64/64 | 117/109 | 34/38 | 100/109 | 55/56 | NA/NA | 49/44 | 4a |
RESET [12] | 2013 | RCT | 269/274 | 12 | 63/64 | 177/150 | 85/82 | 165/165 | 55/54 | NA/NA | 58/47 | 5a |
YJ Youn [22] | 2011 | Observational | 125/216 | 36 | 60/61 | 93/136 | 34/71 | 28/24 | 45/48 | 3/6 | 94/125 | 8 |
YW Yoon [23] | 2013 | Observational | 662/912 | 12 | 61/63 | 428/592 | 184/270 | 403/512 | NA/NA | NA/NA | 167/236 | 8 |
SG Ahn [24] | 2013 | Observational | 49/36 | 24 | 65/65 | 30/22 | 13/11 | 14/9 | 54/56 | 5/2 | 16/14 | 7 |
IRIS-DES [25] | 2013 | Observational | 1616/1628 | 24 | 62/64 | 1115/1034 | 500/516 | 645/548 | 60/59 | 48/57 | 492/478 | 7 |
Hernandez [26] | 2014 | Observational | 505/505 | 36 | 66/67 | 404/397 | 183/175 | 314/284 | 55/55 | 35/31 | 148/161 | 8 |
SJ Hong [27] | 2014 | Observational | 206/328 | 24 | 62/63 | 159/234 | 62/124 | 89/116 | NA/NA | NA/NA | 58/93 | 9 |
XF Gao [28] | 2014 | Observational | 337/679 | 12 | 66/67 | 274/526 | 109/232 | 228/487 | 59/57 | 88/214 | 111/230 | 9 |