Skip to main content

Table 3 Physician recommendations for statin treatment by intervention group compared to NCEP III guidelines and a tailored treatment approach

From: Providing clinicians with a patient’s 10-year cardiovascular risk improves their statin prescribing: a true experiment using clinical vignettes

 

ATP III NCEP III statin treatment recommendation

Benefit based therapy statin treatment recommendation

Proportion of control group prescribing statin therapy

Proportion of experimental group prescribing statin therapy

Mean difference* [control -experimental groups [95% CI]

Pvalue

Case 1. 52 year-old woman: 10-year risk, 2%; LDL-C (175 mg/dL)

Optional

No statin

0.76

0.67

0.09 [0.007, 0.167]

0.03

Case 2. 70 year-old man male: 10-year risk, 22%; LDL-C (128 mg/dL)

Optional

High-potency statin

0.41

0.73

-0.32 [-0.397, -0.231]

<0.001

Case 3. 55 year-old woman: 10-year risk, 7%; LDL-C (135 mg/dL)

No

Moderate-potency statin

0.74

0.65

0.09 [0.003, 0.166]

0.04

Case 4. 52 year-old man: 10-year risk, 13%; LDL-C (90 mg/dL)

No

Moderate-potency statin

0.20

0.26

-0.06 [-0.136, 0.132]

0.11

Case 5. 71 year-old man: 10-year risk, 21%; LDL-C (96 mg/dL)

No

High-potency statin

0.12

0.27

-0.16 [-0.225, -0.085]

<0.001

  1. * Mean differences between control and experimental groups are representative as +/- numbers. Positive numbers favor statin treatment among respondents in the control group, and negative numbers favor statin treatment among respondents in the intervention group.