Skip to main content

Table 1 Overview of publications, all RCTs

From: Systematic review and meta-analysis of music interventions in hypertension treatment: a quest for answers

First author

Year

Study arm

N

Age (years)

M %

History of HT %

Anti-HT drugs %

Follow-up (days)

Timing of intervention

Description

Bekiroglu [18]a

2013

M

30

75.5 (7.1)

57

100

90

28

1×/day

Turkish Classical

  

C

30

78.2 (6.1)

57

100

90

  

Resting Period

Modesti [2]

2010

M

26

58.0 (−)

62

100

77

180

1×/day

Classical, Celtic, Indian

  

C

29

58.0 (−)

55

100

73

  

Music Guided Slow-Breathing (Buteyko-Pranayama)

Zanini [19]a

2009

M

23

66.5 (9.1)

30

100

100

84

1×/week

Recreation, Improvisation, Composition, Listening of musicb

  

C

22

67.2 (9.6)

55

100

100

  

No Intervention (Standard Medical Therapy)

Chan [20]a

2009

M

23

>60

44

61

-

28

1×/day-1×/week

Western-, Chinese-, Asian Classical, Western Jazz

  

C

24

>60

46

67

-

  

Resting Period

Tang [25]

2009

M

22

85.0 (5.0)

18

59

32

84

3×/week

Mozart

  

C

19

86.0 (6.0)

11

68

42

  

Audio Relaxation Program Training (Revitalizer II)

Altena [24]

2009

M

15

59.0 (11.7)

53

100

100

63

Preferably daily

Slow Music

  

C

15

60.0 (11.0)

47

100

100

  

Resperate® (Device Guided Breathing Exercises)

Pandic [22]

2008

M

22

66.5 (8.3)

18

100

77

112

3×/week

Relaxing Music

  

C

31

70.4 (8.7)

32

100

77

  

Resperate® (Device Guided Breathing Exercises)

Logtenberg [23]

2007

M

15

59.0 (11.7)

67

100

100

56

1×/day

Various Kinds of Music

  

C

15

62.7 (6.0)

20

100

100

  

Resperate® (Device Guided Breathing Exercises)

Schein [21]

2001

M

29

56.5 (8.0)

39

100

76

56

1×/day

Quiet Synthesized Music with Non-Identifiable Rhythm

  

C

32

57.8 (9.4)

56

100

91

  

Breathe with Interactive Music (BIM) Device

Grossman [26]

2001

M

15

50.0 (4.0)

67

100

53

56

1×/day

Quiet Synthesized Music with Non-Identifiable Rhythm

  

C

18

52.0 (12.0)

72

100

56

  

Breathe with Interactive Music (BIM) Device

  1. RCT randomized controlled trial, M music arm, C control arm, HT hypertension
  2. aStudy with Resting period/No intervention as control group
  3. bThis study used music therapy whereas the others used recorded music interventions